CNN debuts four-part series on wild horse controversy

Captured paint mare and her foal
at Broken Arrow holding facility
Photo: Cat Kindsfather
No use without express written permission

In today's first segment of "Mustang Roundup: Taking the wild out of the West," a four-part series to be aired on CNN's American Morning, the cable network thrust the controversy over wild horse roundups into renewed national prominence, with a piece about the recent Lahontan "Gather," during which more than 100 mustangs were captured from the 11,000-acre Lahontan Herd Management Area (HMA) east of Carson City, Nevada.  

The one-day Lahontan roundup was held on Wednesday, November 17th, 2010, and CNN reporters Kim Segal andJohn Zarrella were there, along with videographer Carl Mrozac, and several independent observers, including Richard Couto of Animal Recovery Mission, Lacy Dalton of Let 'Em Run Foundation, Bonnie Matton of the Wild Horse Preservation League, and Simone Netherlands of Respect 4 Horses.  They witnessed the chase and entrapment of 117 wild horses, and it's the graphic footage of what happened there that CNN unveiled today.

"In their eyes, you see who they are," intones the narrator of the powerful two-minute piece, "rugged, powerful, independent:  they are the wild mustangs of the American west."

Part of the footage depicts a horrifying sequence in which the helicopter contractor seems to attack a lone burro with the skids of his vehicle, while the voiceover says, "Here, a helicopter chases one single burro, eventually knocking it over.  It staggers off."  The reporters quote Simone Netherlands, who characterizes the helicopter chases as "brutal," adding, "It's barbaric and it does not need to be done this way."

The BLM ultimately determined that two of the "wild" horses it had chased from the Lahontan HMA were privately owned, identifying a mare and her foal who had "domestic brands."  Another yearling colt was euthanized by Dr. Richard Sanford at the Palomino Valley holding facility because he "had an old healed fracture or dislocation involving his right hind fetlock joint.  He was noticeably lame (Grade III) and in much worse body condition (Body Condition II) than his herd mates.  His foot was severely deformed from the injury."

Only seven horses (two stallions and five mares) were released back into the Lahontan HMA a day after their capture, on Thursday, November 18th.

CNN will air Part II of "Mustang Roundup: Taking the wild out of the West" on Tuesday, January 4th, on American Morning.

It wasn't a good year for wild horses

Photo:  Cat Kindsfather
No use without written permission

On January 1st, 2010, a six-month-old colt became the first of the year's multitude of fatalities among wild horses who were chased from their western ranges and put behind bars, having forever lost their freedom and sometimes, their lives.


It happened during the infamous Calico Complex roundup in Nevada, as described in the subsequent necropsy report by Dr. Albert Kane, the BLM's onsite veterinarian:

"The (helicopter) pilot (gathering horses) reported this colt lied down twice while moving just 1/2 mile from the original location of the band of horses.  The second time, he radioed to the trap for wranglers to come with a trailer and assist the colt, as he seemed unlikely to make it to the trap.

I accompanied the wranglers to the location.  We arrived to the colt's location about 10 minutes after the call from the pilot.  On arrival, he was found dead, lying in left lateral recumbency, with no signs of struggle or agonal movements apparent in the surrounding snow."

As a result of his post-mortem examination, Dr. Kane ultimately concluded that the colt had died of "left side heart failure."  But, as the BLM and its veterinarians have done in case after case when wild horses have died from the stress of the helicopter chase, Dr. Kane went out of his way to shift the culpability for the colt's demise from the BLM and its contractor, noting that "Death (was) caused by acute pulmonary artery rupture attributable to a pre-existing, probably congenital heart condition."  And even though Dr. Kane specifically characterized the colt's death as "gather related," the BLM's Calico updates said it was not.

More than 120 wild horses of the 1922 who were scoured from the Calico Herd Management Areas ultimately perished, and untold numbers of unborn foals were aborted from their dams' stress-wrenched bodies before they could ever take a breath.

Word games, deception, cruelty, and a macabre twisting of the truth permeated the BLM's relentless campaign to sweep wild horses from their rightful ranges in 2010.  And at the end of the year, a long-awaited audit report from the Office of the Inspector General simply rubber-stamped the wrangling and warehousing techniques of a federal agency that is seemingly spiraling out of control.

With the keynote appearance of BLM Director Bob Abbey at next week's pro-slaughter Summit of the Horse, the agency's true agenda is starting to come into clearer view.  Anyone who cares about horses should be alarmed.  It is a time to fight back, not to shrink back, lest 2011 bring more of the same misery to America's wild horses.